Best Halloween Candy

Candy season is here and we've got all the seasonal treats for you to splurge on


Each holiday season, we gather candy from the most popular producers in our area and nationwide and sit down to a full-on candy tasting (feasting) to pick out the best candy for every craving. Halloween, with its candy corn, chocolate and other dental fear-inducing treats, always provides one of the best candy tastings of the year.

This year, the array of candy sent our way for tasting was better than ever. We received hand-painted pumpkin truffles, "unjunked" candy bars and everything in between. That's right, unjunked candy bars. But were they any good? Read on to find out!
Related Imagery
Li-Lac Chocolate Witch
Godiva Pumpkin Truffles
Lake Champlain Revel Chocolates
Cadbury Screme Egg

Best Spooky Chocolate Sculpture - Li-Lac

No matter how many times I see them, small chocolate sculptures continue to amaze me. This Halloween season, plenty of chocolate brands are advertising their own themed chocolate art, with the best including Godiva's Milk and White Chocolate Mummy ($10) and Lake Champlain's Dark Chocolate Spooky Cat ($11). This year, our favorites are those done by Li-Lac in New York City. Three dimensional chocolate witches and jack o'lanterns are adorable treats or gifts come Halloween, and these are made with smooth, creamy milk and dark chocolate to boot.

Li-Lac Halloween chocolates range in price from $1.85 for Pumpkin and Ghost Pops to $25 for a larger chocolate Witch. Our favorites of the bunch are the smaller witches ($8.50) and the clever Mummy in a Coffin ($6.50).

Best Halloween-Inspired Truffles - Lake Champlain

There are many a Halloween-appropriate candy come October, especially when the shelves start filling up with all those snack- and fun-sized versions of the regular candies we love. But what about when you want something special, with a slightly more sophisticated nature? Perhaps, to give as a gift to a friend or significant other. These are times when truffles are the best possible option, and thanks to companies like Godiva, Norman Love and Lake Champlain, there are plenty of autumn and Halloween inspired truffles on the market.

There are some real stand-outs from Godiva, we loved the Pumpkin Cheesecake Truffle, most specifically, and Norman Love's beautiful little truffle gems are always a hit. This go around, Lake Champlain's fall flavors won as our favorites. Of the "Revel" line ($36/box), our three favorites were Vermont Creme Fraiche, for its lightly cheesecake taste, Chipotle Cinnamon, which really kicked you in the mouth with its chipotle heat, and the Whistle Pig Straight Rye Whiskey, which we couldn't help but love with its strong but not cloying whiskey taste.

Best Updated Version of a Halloween Classic - Reese's Pumpkin

We know, we know, the pumpkin-shaped Reese's ($1) is not that much of an update, but sometimes you just have to stick to the classics. This candy update section proved just that.

While Caramel Apple Milky Ways ($3.49) were edible once past the initial overwhelming apple cinnamon oatmeal flavor, the candies that stuck closer to their more trusted versions were favored. And, with the slightly different shape, much like that of the Reese's Eggs come Easter season, the chocolate-to-peanut butter ratio in a Reese's Pumpkin does change, so it's not exactly the same beast as what we're chomping on year round.

One thing we do not recommend: Candy Corn M&M's ($3). Only two of the many in the Snooth Media office were able to stomach these. Their cloying sweetness was more of a match between Skittle and white chocolate than anything else, but if you're one of the few who find that appealing, this might be right up your alley. A warning though, they taste almost nothing like candy corn (maybe that is a recommendation, for some).

Most Unique Entry - Unreal Candy

Calling themselves the "unjunked" candy bar, Unreal provides candy treats similar to the ones we know and love, but with higher protein and lower sugar. Surprisingly, they don't taste half bad. Of the four, including takes on Snickers, Milky Way, Reese's Cup and Peanut M&M's, we most preferred the Unreal 5, or "unjunked" Milky Way, and the Unreal 8, or "unjunked" Snickers. Both were pleasant and incredibly reminiscent of the regular bar, without much difference other than the textures being a little more dense. Our least favorite of the bunch was the Unreal77, a peanut butter cup. To us, this tasted most like a protein bar. To the unassuming tongue, though, these are perfectly plausible stand-ins for our favorite candies.

Unreal candies are $1.29/bar or $4.99/bag.

The Rest

Of course our candy tasting covered all of the regular trick-or-treating treats we've learned to love over the years, including Mr. Goodbar, Kit Kat, Snickers and more. Most of us know how these taste, but we all have our personal favorites.

Are you a peanut butter cup lover? Or do you prefer the toothsome chew of a Milk Dud? Or what about the love 'em or hate 'em Whoppers? Let us know your favorite Halloween candy and what you plan to present to trick-or-treaters  this year in the comments below!

Mentioned in this article


  • Snooth User: tlbgrip
    831205 7

    What are the green coffin shaped items in the lower right of the picture on the blog?

    Oct 15, 2012 at 5:40 PM

  • Snooth User: Kate Statton
    Hand of Snooth
    853836 1,080

    Those boxes are from Norman Love, all of there truffle sets come in beautiful mint green cigar-like boxes.

    Oct 15, 2012 at 6:09 PM

  • Snooth User: Kate Statton
    Hand of Snooth
    853836 1,080

    *their -- oopsies!

    Oct 15, 2012 at 6:09 PM

  • Snooth User: HallStars4
    245383 12

    We made peanut butta filled chocolate skulls and they were great. The peanut butter filling gave the eyes an amber glow and when the thin layer of chocolate bin the eye socket softened the peanut butter filling began to ooze out the sockets for a wonderful "wormy" look.

    Oct 15, 2012 at 9:22 PM

  • Snooth User: Kate Statton
    Hand of Snooth
    853836 1,080

    Great idea, HallStars! If you're looking for any other fun and creative Halloween snacks, check out this previous What's Cookin' post:

    Oct 16, 2012 at 12:09 PM

  • Snooth User: HallStars4
    245383 12

    Thanks Kate! I checked them out. Very cute. You have a great imagination.

    Oct 17, 2012 at 4:02 PM

Add a Comment

Search Articles

Best Wine Deals

See More Deals

Snooth Media Network